I am really satisfied with this mascara! It stays in place until makeup removal, even if you take a nap. 🥰 I have struggled with mascaras my whole life, as none have felt like they could last more than an hour without smudging from the tips of the lashes and the lower lashes and spreading on the eyelids, regardless of waterproofness, setting sprays, primers, or powders. This has changed my life as I can swipe on mascara in the morning and it lasts all day no matter what I do, and I don’t have to check the mirror and fix mascara mess on my eyelids. And removal is so effortless as I don’t have to scrub the mascara off with oils and makeup removers separately.