I've been using this in the color Bleach for about 1 year now and it's really good, creamy, easy to use, good pigment, and lasts a LONG time.
However, I just bought the color Graphite to use as a base for black eyeshadow, and unfortunately, it's almost the opposite, very patchy, drier, and doesn't last nearly as long. They now have a different look on the packaging, so I'm wondering if the formula has also changed or if it's dependent on the color. A bit disappointing since the other one was so good.